Lab Anim Res.  2024 Jun;40(2):287-291. 10.1186/s42826-024-00206-6.

Artificial intelligence generated clinical score sheets: looking at the two faces of Janus

• Berce C

• KMID: 2557896
• DOI: http://doi.org/10.1186/s42826-024-00206-6

Abstract

In vivo experiments are increasingly using clinical score sheets to ensure minimal distress to the animals. A score sheet is a document that includes a list of specific symptoms, behaviours and intervention guidelines, all balanced to for an objective clinical assessment of experimental animals. Artificial Intelligence (AI) technologies are increasingly being applied in the field of preclinical research, not only in analysis but also in documentation processes, reflecting a significant shift towards more technologically advanced research methodologies. The present study explores the application of Large Language Models (LLM) in generating score sheets for an animal welfare assessment in a preclinical research setting. Focusing on a mouse model of inflammatory bowel disease, the study evaluates the performance of three LLM – ChatGPT-4, ChatGPT-3.5, and Google Bard – in creating clinical score sheets based on specified criteria such as weight loss, stool consistency, and visible fecal blood. Key parameters evaluated include the consistency of structure, accuracy in representing severity levels, and appropriateness of intervention thresholds. The findings reveal a duality in LLM-generated score sheets: while some LLM consistently structure their outputs effectively, all models exhibit notable variations in assigning numerical values to symptoms and defining intervention thresholds accurately. This emphasizes the dual nature of AI performance in this field—its potential to create useful foundational drafts and the critical need for professional review to ensure precision and reliability. The results highlight the significance of balancing AI-generated tools with expert oversight in preclinical research.

Keyword

Score sheets; Preclinical; LLM; Artificial intelligence; In vivo