Comparison of Multiple Scoring Systems and CT Severity Index for Systemic and Local Complications of Acute Pancreatitis

Kim, Nam Ryeol; Jung, Whan Hun; Kang, Seok Hyung; Min, Youn Ki; Cho, Min Young; Suh, Sung Ock; Kim, Young Chul; Whang, Cheung Wung

Abstract

PURPOSE: The progression of mortality of acute pancreatitis occurs in two different phases. One occurs earlier in the course of the disease and results from systemic complications such as renal failure and ARDS. Another occurs later and results from local complications such as a pancreatic abscess, an infected phlegmon or a pseudocyst. The values of the Ranson score, the Glasgow (Imrie) score, the Acute Physiology and the Chronic Health Evaluation (APACHE II) score and computerized tomography severity index (CTSI) of Balthazar were compared in an evaluation and monitoring of acute pancreatitis, in which we mainly predicted the occurrence of systemic and local complications of the attacks in 31 patients.
METHODS
Between January 1997 and December 1999, 31 patients who had a clinical diagnosis of acute pancreatitis which was supported by the presence of a serum amylase that exceeded 200 IU/L and the presenting clinical symptoms were included in this study. We reviewed their medical records and their abdominal CT imaging scans. We calculated the CTSI based on the CT imaging findings with the assistance of a radiologist.
RESULTS
Among the 31 patients, systemic complications had developed in 10 patients and local complications had occurred in 12 patients. In all of the scoring systems including the CTSI, the mean scores of the group who had systemiccomplications were higher than the group with no complication. The accuracy of the Glasgow score (>or=4) and the APACHE II score (48 hours after admission, >or=10) was greater than that of the others. However, only the CTSI was accurately predicted the occurrence of local complications.
CONCLUSION
These results suggest that CTSI should be considered as being a predicting factor when it is combined with multiple scoring systems such as the Ranson score, the Glasgow score or the APACHE II score in order to obtain accurate prediction of the prognosis and the mortality rate in acute pancreatitis.