The Comparison of Restriction Fragment Mass Polymorphism Method with Sequecing Method for the Detection of HBV YMDD Mutants

Sohn, Yong Hak; Yoo, Soo Jin; Yang, Jin Hyuk; Hwang, Sang Hyun; Hong, Sun Pyo; Oh, Heung Bum

Abstract

BACKGROUND
YMDD motif mutants of the hepatitis B virus (HBV) emerged in some chronic hepatitis B patients after prolonged lamivudine treatment. Recently a novel genotyping assay, the restriction fragment mass polymorphism (RFMP) method, was introduced for the detection of YMDD mutations. We compared the performance of the RFMP method with that of sequencing method in chronic hepatitis B patients who had suffered the HBV DNA breakthrough after lamivudine treatment. METHODS: Enrolled in this study were 18 chronic hepatitis B patients who experienced the DNA breakthrough after a period during which HBV DNA was undetectable by Hybrid capture II HBV DNA test (Digene Inc., Gaithersburg, MD, USA). Both sequencing and RFMP methods were used to detect YMDD variants in three phases such as before treatment, before breakthrough and after breakthrough. RESULTS: YMDD mutants were detected in 13 samples (72.2%) by both methods after DNA breakthrough. Among them were two samples with a mixed HBV population detected by RFMP. Before breakthrough, the mutants were detected in three samples (16.7%) by sequencing and four (22.2%) by RFMP, showing discrepant results for two samples. The concordance rate between both methods was 92.6%. CONCLUSIONS: Both sequencing and RFMP methods were highly concordant except in a few cases, so it is suggested that both methods are appropriate in detecting YMDD mutants.