Osteoporos Sarcopenia.  2020 Sep;6(3):151-159. 10.1016/j.afos.2020.08.003.

Is ankle fracture related to low bone mineral density and subsequent fracture? A systematic review

• Therdyothin A
• Phiphopthatsanee N
• Wajanavisit W
• Woratanarat P
• Laohajaroensombat S
• Tawonsawatruk T

• KMID: 2507212
• DOI: http://doi.org/10.1016/j.afos.2020.08.003

Abstract

Objectives
Ankle fractures are common in the elderly. However, their association with osteoporosis remains controversial. This systematic review aims to determine the relationship between ankle fracture and bone mineral density (BMD), and to investigate the risk of subsequent fractures after ankle fracture.
Methods
MEDLINE and Scopus publications were searched from inception to March and April 2019, respectively. Articles were selected by 2 independent reviewers for cross-sectional, cohort, or casecontrol studies comparing BMD or subsequent fracture risk in low-energy ankle fractures patients with that of the normal population. Data extraction was performed by 2 investigators. Discrepancies were resolved with the third reviewer. Quality assessment was conducted using the modified NewcastleOttawa Scale.
Results
Overall, 19 articles were included. The quality assessment showed a generally low-to-moderate risk of bias among studies, mainly due to potential confounders and inadequate follow-up. Of 13 studies exploring BMD in ankle fractured-patients, lower central and peripheral BMD was found in 3 and 2 studies, respectively. The risk of subsequent fracture was examined in 11 studies with relative risks ranging from 0.7 to 4.59. An increased risk of any subsequent fractures in women, both genders, and men was found in 5, 2, and 1 articles, respectively.
Conclusions
Despite the lack of clear association with BMD, the contribution of ankle fracture to increased subsequent fracture risk and its associated microarchitectural changes cannot be overlooked. Moreover, its potential role as an early predictor of future fracture may promote secondary prevention. Further studies with longer follow-up and stricter confounder control are recommended.

Keyword

Osteoporosis; Ankle fracture; Bone mineral density; Fracture prediction; Risk factor