Three different approach to hysterectomy for benign uterine pathology

Hahn, Ho Suap; Choi, Kyu Hong; Kim, Joo Myung; Lee, Hyun Joo; Choi, No Mi; Yoo, Won Sik; Kim, Kyung Yeon; Kim, Nam Sook; Jo, Soo Hee; Hong, Jun Shik

Abstract

OBJECTIVE
To evaluate the rates and clinical outcomes between abdominal hysterectomy (AH), laparoscopic hysterectomy (LH) and vaginal hysterectomy (VH).
METHODS
Medical records of 236 patients who underwent hysterectomy (by one surgeon) for benign uterine pathology between march 2004 and april 2006 were reviewed. Primary outcome measure was the rate of each method of hysterectomy. Secondary outcome measures included perioperative and postoperative outcomes between groups.
RESULTS
The mean age, weight, height, body mass index, and parity in three groups showed no difference. In two hundred and twenty two cases of hysterectomies, the rate of AH was 13.5%, LH 34.2%, and VH 52.3%. Perioperative outcomes of AH, LH and VH were as follows : operative time (83.2+/-27.1 min, 94.2+/-25.2 min, and 50.8+/-15.5 min, respectively), change in hemoglobin (2.3+/-1.5 g/dL, 2.0+/-0.9 g/dL, and 1.3+/-1.1 g/dL, respectively), duration of urinary catheterization (2.0+/-0.2 days, 1.0+/-0.0 days, and 1.0+/-0.4 days, respectively), postoperative hospitalization (5.7+/-1.2 days, 4.7+/-0.9 days, and 4.3+/-1.0 days, respectively), uterine weight (733+/-665 g, 340+/-213 g, and 300+/-156 g, respectively). Uterine weight in the AH group was significantly heavier than in the LH and VH. The benefits of LH versus AH were shorter duration of urinary catheterization and postoperative hospitalization (p<0.05). The benefits of VH versus AH were shorter operative time, a smaller drop in hemoglobin, shorter duration of urinary catheterization and postoperative hospitalization (p<0.05). The benefits of VH versus LH were shorter operative time, a smaller drop in hemoglobin, and postoperative hospitalization (p<0.05). There were no differences in complications of AH, LH and VH (13.3%, 10.5%, and 9.5%, respectively p=0.825).
CONCLUSIONS
Eighty six point five percent of hysterectomy can be done vaginal or laparoscopic approach. When there is a concerted effort to increase laparoscopic or vaginal hysterectomy, abdominal hysterectomy can decrease without increasing complication rate.