J Korean Geriatr Soc.  2002 Mar;6(1):55-66.

A Comparison of NSAID and Intramuscular Stimulation Therapy Effectiveness in the Female Patient with Chronic Shoulder Pain

• Ahn SL
• Woo JW
• Kim JA
• Yoon DK
• Cho KH
• Jang JA
• Hong MH
• Kim HJ
• Park YK

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Chronic shoulder pain draws the attention of doctors since it is a very common and serious disease at primary care level. The patients with this pain usually have a tendency to see many doctors, to take an abundance of medication, and sometimes to even suffer from depression. The pain and the symp- toms thereof often disable the patients in their every day lives. This study aims to seek the most efficient way of treatment between two therapies, namely, the existing drug therapy based on NSAID and the intramuscular stimulation(herein after IMS) therapy, which has re- cently been introduced, by comparing them in accordance with the following method.
METHODS
The two therapies were applied for 3 weeks to female patients aged between 50 and 70 who had visited a hospital over a period of more than 3 months due to this type of pain. The patients were randomly given each therapy although the treatment and monitoring was done by the same physiotherapist. The monitoring was performed four times, the day before the start of treatment, 1 week, 2 weeks and 3 weeks after respectively. It measured the following elements: (1) pain scale by VAS(Visual Analogue Scale), (2) Sleep hygiene scale by VAS, (3) ROM(Range of Motion), Repeated measure ANOVA was used for analysis.
RESULTS
While both therapies reduced the pain significantly during the 3 weeks, the study showed that IMS was more effective than the drug therapy in every element monitored(p<0.05). IMS turned out to be more effective the 1st week in every measured element, however, the drug therapy was more effective the 3rd week if compared to the 2nd week in terms of Sleep VAS score.
CONCLUSION
IMS is more effective in easing chro nic shoulder pain since it has better results than NSAID in pain VAS score, sleep VAS score and ROM.

Keyword

Shoulder area; IMS; Chronic pain

MeSH Terms

Chronic Pain
Depression
Drug Therapy
Female*
Humans
Hygiene
Physical Therapists
Primary Health Care
Shoulder Pain*
Shoulder*