Tuberc Respir Dis.  2004 Aug;57(2):168-179. 10.4046/trd.2004.57.2.168.

An Evaluation of the Use of Statistical Methods in the Journal of Tuberculosis and Respiratory Diseases

• Koh WJ
• Lee SJ
• Kang MJ
• Lee HJ

• KMID: 2132499
• DOI: http://doi.org/10.4046/trd.2004.57.2.168

Abstract

BACKGROUND: The statistical analysis is an essential procedure ensuring that the results of researches are based on evidences rather than opinion. The purpose of this study is to evaluate which statistical techniques are used and whether these statistical methods are used appropriately or not in the journal of Tuberculosis and Respiratory Diseases.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
We reviewed 185 articles reported in the journal of Tuberculosis and Respiratory Diseases in 1999. We evaluated the validity of used statistical methods based upon the checklist that was developed on the basis of the guideline for statistical reporting in articles for medical journals by International Committee of Medical Journal Editors.
RESULTS
Among 185 articles, original articles and case reports were 110 (59.5%) and 61 (33.0%) respectively. In 112 articles excluding case reports and reviews, statistical techniques were used in 107 articles (95.5%). In 94 articles (83.9%) descriptive and inferential methods were used, while in 13 (11.6%) articles only descriptive methods were used. With the types of inferential statistical techniques, comparison of means was most commonly used (64/94, 68.1%), followed by contingency table (43/94, 45.7%) and correlation or regression (18/94, 19.1%). Among the articles in which descriptive methods were used, 83.2% (89/107) showed inappropriate central tendency and dispersion. In the articles in which inferential methods were used, improper methods were applied in 88.8% (79/89) and the most frequent misuse of statistical methods was inappropriate use of parametric methods (35/89, 39.3%). Only 14 articles (13.1%) were satisfactory in utilization of statistical methodology.
CONCLUSION
Most of the statistical errors found in the journal were misuses of statistical methods related to basic statistics. This study suggests that researchers should be more careful when they describe and apply statistical methods and more extensive statistical refereeing system would be needed.

Keyword

Statistics; Periodicals; Medical Journalism; Pulmonary Disease; Korea

MeSH Terms

Checklist
Journalism, Medical
Korea
Lung Diseases
Tuberculosis*