Thallium-201 SPECT in Differential Diagnosis of Malignancy from Benign Pathology in Patients with a Solitary Pulmonary Lesion

Ahn, Byeong Cheol; Lee, Jae Tae; Chun, Kyung Ah; Kim, Dong Hwan; Sohn, Sang Kyun; Kim, Chang Ho; Park, Jae Yong; Jeong, Tae Hoon; Lee, Kyu Bo; Kim, Chun K

Abstract

PURPOSE: T1-201 SPECT has been used in differentiating benign and malignant pulmonary lesions. While its sensitivity may be high, the specificity and predictive values are reported to be variable depending on the type of benign lung lesion. The purpose of this study was to prospectively assess the efficacy of T1-201 SPECT for differentiating benign and malignant single pulmonary lesions in a population with a high prevalence of begin pulmonary lesions, especially, tuberculosis.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
One-hundred thirty-three patients, having 89 malignant and 44 benign lesions(23 active tuberculosis, 5 inactive tuberculosis, 3 aspergilloma, 3 focal pneumonia, 2 thymoma, and 8 others), were imaged using a dual-headed system at 15 minute(early) and 3 hour (delayed) following administration of 111MBq T1-201. The images were read visually and lesion-to-background ratios(L/B) were obtained from transverse tomographic slices. Retention index was expressed as [(delayed L/B-early L/B) / early L/B].
RESULTS
82/89(92%) and 83/89(93%) of the malignant lesions were visually positive on the early and delayed images, and 27/44(61%) and 26/44(59%) of the benign lesions wefe also between the mean L/B's of the malignant and benign lesions, L/B was not useful for differentiating the two due to a large overlap. There was no difference in retention indices.
CONCLUSION
Despite of its high sensitivity, the specificity of T1-201 SPECT was unacceptably low in patients with active benign lesions. The positive and negative predictive values for lung cancer in a population with a high prevalence of the benign single pulmonary lesion was only marginal.