J Korean Fract Soc.  2002 Apr;15(2):106-113. 10.12671/jksf.2002.15.2.106.

Surgical Treatment of Type II distal clavicle end Fracture

• Chung PH
• Kang S
• Chae DJ
• Kim JP
• Lee SH

• KMID: 1999388
• DOI: http://doi.org/10.12671/jksf.2002.15.2.106

Abstract

PURPOSE: Many authors have supported open reduction and internal fixation of type II distal clavicle fractures because of high rates of nonunion and delayed union after conservative treatment. Authors analyzed thirty-nine cases of type II distal clavicle fractures which had been treated operatively and reviewed the result of operative treatment retrospectively.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
We evaluated 39 unstable distal 1/3 clavicular fractures with operative treatment from May 1992 to December 1999 and followed up for at least 1 year. According to the classification of Rockwood, type IIa was 28cases and IIb was 11 cases. We treated all the cases by open reduction, such as transacromial pin fixation in 27 cases, and plate and screws with or without bone graft in 12 cases. The operative method was chosen in operative field. RESULT: We analyzed the results in term of the time to radiologic union, functional evaluation, and complications. Average time to union was 8.5 weeks in the cases of transacromial pin fixation and 12.7 weeks in the cases using plate and screws with or without bone graft. Functional results was evaluated by classification of functional results by Kona et al. In cases of transacromial pin fixation, excellent result was 13 cases and good was 14 cases. In cases of plate and screws, excellent result was 4 cases, good 6 cases, fair 1 case, and poor was 1 case. The complications of transacromial pin fixation were 4 cases of pin site infection and 1 case of pin migration. But, neither nonunion nor deep infection was appeared. The complication of plate and screws was 2 cases of metal failure in which were fixated by only two cortical screws on distal fragment.
CONCLUSION
We concluded that minimal open reduction and transacromial pin fixation is thought to be good method in treatment of distal 1/3 clavicular fracture in regard to the time to union, functional results, and complications.

Keyword

clavicle; distal end fracture; transacromial pin fixation; plate & screw fixation

MeSH Terms

Classification
Clavicle*
Retrospective Studies
Transplants