Detectability of Ektaspeed Puls Film, Digitized and Digora Images for artificial periapical bone lesions

Cho, Bong Hae; Nah, Kyung Soo; Lee, Hee Joo

Abstract

The comparative detectability of the artificial periapical defects among Ektaspeed Plus film, digitized and digora images was evaluated. The artificail defects were made in the cancellous bone and cancellous-cortical junction with the size of 1.0x0.8mm2, 1.4x1.1mm2 and 2.8x2.2mm2. The defects in cancellous-cortical junction extended into cortical bone with the depth of 0, 0.5 and 1.0 mm. The results were as follows : 1. In junctional defects Ektaspeed Plus film for 2.8x12.2mm2 defect showed the highest detectability. But siginificant difference were only found between Ektaspeed Plus films and digitized images(p<0.05). 2. Almost all defects within cacellous bone were not detected except a few digitized and Digora images for the size of 2.8x2.2mm2. Digora images for them showed significant differences with Ektaspeed Plus films and digitized images(p<0.05). 3. The sensitinity of all imaging modalities were 0.9 or 1.0 in junctional defects for the size of 1.4x2.2mm2 and 2.8x2.2mm2. For cancellous defects, Digora image showed the highest sensitivity of 0.6 for the size of 2.8x2.2mm2. 4. Siginificant differences for change of exposure time were found in most group of Ektaspeed Plus films and digitized images(p<0.05). But there was no significant differences in Digora images for cacellous defects.