Korean J Radiol.  2021 Oct;22(10):1697-1707. 10.3348/kjr.2021.0223.

Review of Statistical Methods for Evaluating the Performance of Survival or Other Time-to-Event Prediction Models (from Conventional to Deep Learning Approaches)

• Park SY
• Park JE
• Kim H
• Park SH

• KMID: 2520627
• DOI: http://doi.org/10.3348/kjr.2021.0223

Abstract

The recent introduction of various high-dimensional modeling methods, such as radiomics and deep learning, has created a much greater diversity in modeling approaches for survival prediction (or, more generally, time-to-event prediction). The newness of the recent modeling approaches and unfamiliarity with the model outputs may confuse some researchers and practitioners about the evaluation of the performance of such models. Methodological literacy to critically appraise the performance evaluation of the models and, ideally, the ability to conduct such an evaluation would be needed for those who want to develop models or apply them in practice. This article intends to provide intuitive, conceptual, and practical explanations of the statistical methods for evaluating the performance of survival prediction models with minimal usage of mathematical descriptions. It covers from conventional to deep learning methods, and emphasis has been placed on recent modeling approaches. This review article includes straightforward explanations of C indices (Harrell’s C index, etc.), timedependent receiver operating characteristic curve analysis, calibration plot, other methods for evaluating the calibration performance, and Brier score.

Keyword

Time-to-event; Survival; Prediction model; Predictive model; Artificial intelligence; Machine learning; Deep learning; Performance; Accuracy; Discrimination; Calibration