Saf Health Work.  2020 Mar;11(1):61-70. 10.1016/j.shaw.2019.11.001.

Evaluation of a New Workplace Protection Factor–Measuring Method for Filtering Facepiece Respirator

• Sun C
• Thelen C
• Sanz IS
• Wittmann A

• KMID: 2506684
• DOI: http://doi.org/10.1016/j.shaw.2019.11.001

Abstract

Background
This study aims to assess whether the TSI PortaCount (Model 8020) is a measuring instrument comparable with the flame photometer. This would provide an indication for the suitability of the PortaCount for determining the workplace protection factor for particulate filtering facepiece respirators.
Methods
The PortaCount (with and without the N95-Companion™) was compared with a stationary flame photometer from Moores (Wallisdown) Ltd (Type 1100), which is a measuring instrument used in the procedure for determining the total inward leakage of the particulate filtering facepiece respirator in the European Standard. Penetration levels of sodium chloride aerosol through sample respirators of two brands (A and B) were determined by the two measuring systems under laboratory conditions. For each brand, thirty-six measurements were conducted. The samples were split into groups according to their protection level, conditioning before testing, and aerosol concentration. The relationship between the gauged data from two measuring systems was determined. In addition, the particle size distribution inside the respirator and outside the respirator was documented. Linear regression analysis was used to calculate the association between the PortaCount (with and without the N95-Companion™) and the flame photometer.
Results
A linear relationship was found between the raw data scaled with the PortaCount (without N95-Companion™) and the data detected by the flame photometer (R² = 0.9704) under all test conditions. The distribution of particle size was found to be the same inside and outside the respirator in almost all cases.
Conclusion
Based on the obtained data, the PortaCount may be applicable for the determination of workplace protection factor.

Keyword

filtering facepiece respirator; flame photometer; nominal protection factor; PortaCount; workplace protection factor