J Vet Sci.  2020 Mar;21(2):e14. 10.4142/jvs.2020.21.e14.

Evaluation of the cost-effectiveness of ASF detection with or without the use of on-field tests in different scenarios, in Sardinia

• Cappai S
• Loi F
• Rolesu S
• Coccollone A
• Laddomada A
• Sgarangella F
• Masala S
• Bitti G
• Floris V
• Desini P

• KMID: 2506185
• DOI: http://doi.org/10.4142/jvs.2020.21.e14

Abstract

African swine fever (ASF) is a highly contagious disease of domestic pigs and wild boars (WBs). Without a vaccine, early antibody and antigen detection and rapid diagnosis are crucial for the effective prevention of the disease and the employment of control measures. In Sardinia, where 3 different suid populations coexisted closely for a long time, the disease persists since 1978. The recent ASF eradication plan involves more stringent measures to combat free-ranging pigs and any kind of illegality in the pig industry. However, critical issues such as the low level of hunter cooperation with veterinary services and the time required for ASF detection in the WBs killed during the hunting season still remain. Considering the need to deliver true ASF negative carcasses as early as possible, this study focuses on the evaluation and validation of a duplex pen-side test that simultaneously detects antibodies and antigens specific to ASF virus, to improve molecular diagnosis under field conditions. The main goal was to establish the specificity of the two pen-side tests performed simultaneously and to determine their ability to detect the true ASF negative carcasses among the hunted WBs. Blood and organ samples of the WBs hunted during the 2018/2019 hunting seasons were obtained. A total of 160 animals were tested using the pen-side kit test; samples were collected for virological and serological analyses. A specificity of 98% was observed considering the official laboratory tests as gold standards. The new diagnostic techniques could facilitate faster and cost-effective control of the disease.

Keyword

African swine fever; pen-side test; ost effectiveness analysis; Sardinia; hunting season management

Reference

References

1. Alonso C, Borca M, Dixon L, Revilla Y, Rodriguez F, Escribano JM. Ictv Report Consortium. ICTV virus taxonomy profile: Asfaviridae. J Gen Virol. 2018; 99:613–614.

2. Dixon LK, Twigg SR, Baylis SA, Vydelingum S, Bristow C, Hammond JM, Smith GL. Nucleotide sequence of a 55 kbp region from the right end of the genome of a pathogenic African swine fever virus isolate (Malawi LIL20/1). J Gen Virol. 1994; 75:1655–1684.

3. Dixon LK, Escribano JM, Martins C, Rock DL, Salas ML. Asfarviridae. Fauquet CM, Mayo MA, Maniloff J, Desselberger U, Ball LA, editors. (eds.).Virus Taxonomy. VIII Report of the ICTV. pp.p. 135–143. Elsevier/Academic Press;London: 2005.

4. Anderson EC, Hutchings GH, Mukarati N, Wilkinson PJ. African swine fever virus infection of the bushpig (Potamochoerus porcus) and its significance in the epidemiology of the disease. Vet Microbiol. 1998; 62:1–15.

5. Penrith ML, Thomson GR, Bastos AD, Etter EM. African swine fever. Coetzer JAW, Tustin RC, editors. (eds.).Infectious Diseases of Livestock. 2nd ed.pp.p. 1088–1119. Oxford University Press;Cape Town: 2004.

6. Blome S, Gabriel C, Beer M. Pathogenesis of African swine fever in domestic pigs and European wild boar. Virus Res. 2013; 173:122–130.

7. Beltran-Alcrudo D, Falco JR, Raizman E, Dietze K. Transboundary spread of pig diseases: the role of international trade and travel. BMC Vet Res. 2019; 15:64.

8. Couacy-Hymann E, Kouakou KV, Achenbach JE, Kouadio L, Koffi YM, Godji HP, Adjé KE, Oulaï J, Pell-Minhiaud HJ, Lamien CE. Re-emergence of genotype I of African swine fever virus in Ivory Coast. Transbound Emerg Dis. 2019; 66:882–896.

9. Zhou X, Li N, Luo Y, Liu Y, Miao F, Chen T, Zhang S, Cao P, Li X, Tian K, Qiu HJ, Hu R. Emergence of African swine fever in China, 2018. Transbound Emerg Dis. 2018; 65:1482–1484.

10. Komba EVG, Karimuribo ED, Kanemanema MC. Socioeconomic impact of African swine fever outbreak of 2011 and its epidemiology in Isoka District of Zambia. Tanzan Vet J. 2018; 29:37–47.

11. Zepeda C. Chapter 1.3. The social impact of disease control and eradication programs: case studies. Morilla A, Yoon KJ, Zimmerman JJ, editors. (eds.).Trends in Emerging Viral Infections of Swine. pp.p. 17–20. Iowa State Press;Iowa City: 2002.

12. Saatkamp HW, Berentsen PB, Horst HS. Economic aspects of the control of classical swine fever outbreaks in the European Union. Vet Microbiol. 2000; 73:221–237.

13. World Animal Health Information Database (WAHIS Interface). African Swine Fever, Hungary, (Follow-up report No. 11). World Organisation for Animal Health (OIE);Paris: 2019.

14. Jori F, Vial L, Penrith ML, Pérez-Sánchez R, Etter E, Albina E, Michaud V, Roger F. Review of the sylvatic cycle of African swine fever in sub-Saharan Africa and the Indian ocean. Virus Res. 2013; 173:212–227.

15. Penrith ML, Bastos AD, Etter EM, Beltrán-Alcrudo D. Epidemiology of African swine fever in Africa today: sylvatic cycle versus socio-economic imperatives. Transbound Emerg Dis. 2019; 66:672–686.

16. Anon. Bruciati Ventimila Maiali. Il Messaggero Sardo;Cagliari: 1978.

17. Baggiani P. La Peste Suina è Arrivata nel Nuorese. Il Messaggero Sardo;Cagliari: 1978.

18. Laddomada A, Patta C. La Peste Suina Africana a Dieci Anni Dalla Sua Introduzione in Sardegna. Vol.2:Quaderni dell'Istituto Zooprofilattico;Cagliari: 1988.

19. Martínez-López B, Perez AM, Feliziani F, Rolesu S, Mur L, Sánchez-Vizcaíno JM. Evaluation of the risk factors contributing to the African swine fever occurrence in Sardinia, Italy. Front Microbiol. 2015; 6:314.

20. Mur L, Atzeni M, Martínez-López B, Feliziani F, Rolesu S, Sanchez-Vizcaino JM. Thirty-five-year presence of African swine fever in Sardinia: history, evolution and risk factors for disease maintenance. Transbound Emerg Dis. 2016; 63:e165–177.

21. Cappai S, Rolesu S, Coccollone A, Laddomada A, Loi F. Evaluation of biological and socio-economic factors related to persistence of African swine fever in Sardinia. Prev Vet Med. 2018; 152:1–11.

22. Jurado C, Fernández-Carrión E, Mur L, Rolesu S, Laddomada A, Sánchez-Vizcaíno JM. Why is African swine fever still present in Sardinia? Transbound Emerg Dis. 2018; 65:557–566.

23. Laddomada A, Rolesu S, Loi F, Cappai S, Oggiano A, Madrau MP, Sanna ML, Pilo G, Bandino E, Brundu D, Cherchi S, Masala S, Marongiu D, Bitti G, Desini P, Floris V, Mundula L, Carboni G, Pittau M, Feliziani F, Sanchez-Vizcaino JM, Jurado C, Guberti V, Chessa M, Muzzeddu M, Sardo D, Borrello S, Mulas D, Salis G, Zinzula P, Piredda S, De Martini A, Sgarangella F. Surveillance and control of African swine fever in free-ranging pigs in Sardinia. Transbound Emerg Dis. 2019; 66:1114–1119.

24. Wilkinson P. The persistence of African swine fever in Africa and the Mediterranean. Prev Vet Med. 1984; 2:71–82.

25. Laddomada A, Patta C, Oggiano A, Caccia A, Ruiu A, Cossu P, Firinu A. Epidemiology of classical swine fever in Sardinia: a serological survey of wild boar and comparison with African swine fever. Vet Rec. 1994; 134:183–187.

26. Mannelli A, Sotgia S, Patta C, Sarria A, Madrau P, Sanna L, Firinu A, Laddomada A. Effect of husbandry methods on seropositivity to African swine fever virus in Sardinian swine herds. Prev Vet Med. 1997; 32:235–241.

27. Mannelli A, Sotgia S, Patta C, Oggiano A, Carboni A, Cossu P, Laddomada A. Temporal and spatial patterns of African swine fever in Sardinia. Prev Vet Med. 1998; 35:297–306.

28. Rolesu S, Aloi D, Ghironi A, Oggiano N, Oggiano A, Puggioni G, Patta C, Farina S, Montinaro S. Geographic information systems: a useful tool to approach African swine fever surveillance management of wild pig populations. Vet Ital. 2007; 43:463–467.

29. Contini A, Cossu P, Rutili D, Firinu A. African swine fever in Sardinia. Wilkinson PJ, editor. (ed.).CEC/FAO Expert Consultation on African Swine Fever Research. CEC Publication;Sardinia: 1983.

30. Sastre P, Gallardo C, Monedero A, Ruiz T, Arias M, Sanz A, Rueda P. Development of a novel lateral flow assay for detection of African swine fever in blood. BMC Vet Res. 2016; 12:206.

31. Cappai S, Coccollone A, Rolesu S, Oggiano A, Madrau P, Loi F. Costi e benefici nell'utilizzo del pen side test per la ricerca anticorpale nei confronti della Peste Suina Africana. SUMMA Anim Reddito. 2016; 9:57–62.

32. Cappai S, Loi F, Coccollone A, Cocco M, Falconi C, Dettori G, Feliziani F, Sanna ML, Oggiano A, Rolesu S. Evaluation of a commercial field test to detect African swine fever. J Wildl Dis. 2017; 53:602–606.

33. Cappai S, Sanna G, Loi F, Coccollone A, Marrocu E, Oggiano A, Brundu D, Rolesu S, Bandino E. African swine fever detection on field with antigen rapid kit test. J Anim Sci Res. 2018; 2:118.

34. European Food Safety Authority (EFSA). Boklund A, Cay B, Depner K, Földi Z, Guberti V, Masiulis M, Miteva A, More S, Olsevskis E, Šatrán P, Spiridon M, Stahl K, Thulke HH, Viltrop A, Wozniakowski G, Broglia A, Cortinas Abrahantes J, Dhollander S, Gogin A, Verdonck F, Amato L, Papanikolaou A, Gortázar C. Epidemiological analyses of African swine fever in the European Union (November 2017 until November 2018). EFSA J. 2018; 16:e05494.

35. Liu L, Atim S, LeBlanc N, Rauh R, Esau M, Chenais E, Mwebe R, Nelson WM, Masembe C, Nantima N, Ayebazibwe C, Ståhl K. Overcoming the challenges of pen-side molecular diagnosis of African swine fever to support outbreak investigations under field conditions. Transbound Emerg Dis. 2019; 66:908–914.

36. Obuchowski NA. Sample size tables for receiver operating characteristic studies. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2000; 175:603–608.

37. King DP, Reid SM, Hutchings GH, Grierson SS, Wilkinson PJ, Dixon LK, Bastos AD, Drew TW. Development of a TaqMan PCR assay with internal amplification control for the detection of African swine fever virus. J Virol Methods. 2003; 107:53–61.

38. Gardner MJ, Altman DG. Statistics with Confidence: Confidence Intervals and Statistical Guidelines. p. 140. pp,. British Medical Journal;London: 1989.

39. Cebul RD, Hershey JC, Williams SV. Using multiple tests: series and parallel approaches. Clin Lab Med. 1982; 2:871–890.

40. Loi F, Cappai S, Coccollone A, Rolesu S. Standardized risk analysis approach aimed to evaluate the last African swine fever eradication program performance, in Sardinia. Front Vet Sci. 2019; 6:299.