J Korean Neurosurg Soc.  2017 Sep;60(5):498-503. 10.3340/jkns.2017.0202.011.

Biomechanical Comparison of Inter-fragmentary Compression Pressures: Lag Screw versus Herbert Screw for Anterior Odontoid Screw Fixation

• Park JW
• Kim KT
• Sung JK
• Park SH
• Seong KW
• Cho DC

• KMID: 2457955
• DOI: http://doi.org/10.3340/jkns.2017.0202.011

Abstract

OBJECTIVE
The purpose of the present study was to compare inter-fragmentary compression pressures after fixation of a simulated type II odontoid fracture with the headless compression Herbert screw and a half threaded cannulated lag screw.
METHODS
We compared inter-fragmentary compression pressures between 40- and 45-mm long 4.5-mm Herbert screws (n=8 and n=9, respectively) and 40- and 45-mm long 4.0-mm cannulated lag screws (n=7 and n=10, respectively) after insertion into rigid polyurethane foam test blocks (Sawbones, Vashon, WA, USA). A washer load cell was placed between the two segments of test blocks to measure the compression force. Because the total length of each foam block was 42 mm, the 40-mm screws were embedded in the cancellous foam, while the 45-mm screws penetrated the denser cortical foam at the bottom. This enabled us to compare inter-fragmentary compression pressures as they are affected by the penetration of the apical dens tip by the screws.
RESULTS
The mean compression pressures of the 40- and 45-mm long cannulated lag screws were 50.48±1.20 N and 53.88±1.02 N, respectively, which was not statistically significant (p=0.0551). The mean compression pressures of the 40-mm long Herbert screw was 52.82±2.17 N, and was not statistically significant compared with the 40-mm long cannulated lag screw (p=0.3679). However, 45-mm Herbert screw had significantly higher mean compression pressure (60.68±2.03 N) than both the 45-mm cannulated lag screw and the 40-mm Herbert screw (p=0.0049 and p=0.0246, respectively).
CONCLUSION
Our results showed that inter-fragmentary compression pressures of the Herbert screw were significantly increased when the screw tip penetrated the opposite dens cortical foam. This can support the generally recommended surgical technique that, in order to facilitate maximal reduction of the fracture gap using anterior odontoid screws, it is essential to penetrate the apical dens tip with the screw.

Keyword

Fracture gap; Herbert screw; Inter-fragmentary compression; Lag screw; Odontoid fracture; Sawbones

MeSH Terms

Polyurethanes
Polyurethanes

Figure

• 

  Fig. 1 Showing the studied implants; the 4.0-mm cannulated cortical screw (left) and the 4.5-mm headless compression Herbert screw (right).

• 

  Fig. 2 Illustration for test setup. PCF: per cubic foot.

• 

  Fig. 3 Showing the test specimens which was mounted onto a Testometric M 500 Universal testing machine.

• 

  Fig. 4 Mean compression pressures of cannulated lag screws and headless compression Herbert screws (n=7–10/groups).

Reference

References

1. Adla DN, Kitsis C, Miles AW. Compression forces generated by Mini bone screws--a comparative study done on bone model. Injury. 36:65–70. 2005.

2. Andersson S, Rodrigues M, Olerud C. Odontoid fractures: high complication rate associated with anterior screw fixation in the elderly. Eur Spine J. 9:56–59. 2000.

3. Apfelbaum RI, Lonser RR, Veres R, Casey A. Direct anterior screw fixation for recent and remote odontoid fractures. J Neurosurg. 93(2 Suppl):227–236. 2000.

4. Assari S, Darvish K, Ilyas AM. Biomechanical analysis of second-generation headless compression screws. Injury. 43:1159–1165. 2012.

5. Beadel GP, Ferreira L, Johnson JA, King GJ. Interfragmentary compression across a simulated scaphoid fracture--analysis of 3 screws. J Hand Surg Am. 29:273–278. 2004.

6. Börm W, Kast E, Richter HP, Mohr K. Anterior screw fixation in type II odontoid fractures: is there a difference in outcome between age groups? Neurosurgery. 52:1089–1092. discussion 1092–1094. 2003.

7. Burkhart KJ, Nowak TE, Appelmann P, Sternstein W, Rommens PM, Mueller LP. Screw fixation of radial head fractures: compression screw versus lag screw--a biomechanical comparison. Injury. 41:1015–1019. 2010.

8. Chang KW, Liu YW, Cheng PG, Chang L, Suen KL, Chung WL, et al. One Herbert double-threaded compression screw fixation of displaced type II odontoid fractures. J Spinal Disord. 7:62–69. 1994.

9. Chi YL, Wang XY, Xu HZ, Lin Y, Huang QS, Mao FM, et al. Management of odontoid fractures with percutaneous anterior odontoid screw fixation. Eur Spine J. 16:1157–1164. 2007.

10. Cho DC, Sung JK. Is all anterior oblique fracture orientation really a contraindication to anterior screw fixation of type ii and rostral shallow type III odontoid fractures? J Korean Neurosurg Soc. 49:345–350. 2011.

11. Cho DC, Sung JK. Analysis of risk factors associated with fusion failure after anterior odontoid screw fixation. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 37:30–34. 2012.

12. Debernardi A, D’Aliberti G, Talamonti G, Villa F, Piparo M, Collice M. The craniovertebral junction area and the role of the ligaments and membranes. Neurosurgery. 76(Suppl 1):S22–S32. 2015.

13. Fountas KN, Kapsalaki EZ, Karampelas I, Feltes CH, Dimopoulos VG, Machinis TG, et al. Results of long-term follow-up in patients undergoing anterior screw fixation for type II and rostral type III odontoid fractures. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 30:661–669. 2005.

14. Goldstein SA. The mechanical properties of trabecular bone: dependence on anatomic location and function. J Biomech. 20:1055–1061. 1987.

15. Grauer JN, Shafi B, Hilibrand AS, Harrop JS, Kwon BK, Beiner JM, et al. Proposal of a modified, treatment-oriented classification of odontoid fractures. Spine J. 5:123–129. 2005.

16. Grewal R, Assini J, Sauder D, Ferreira L, Johnson J, Faber K. A comparison of two headless compression screws for operative treatment of scaphoid fractures. J Orthop Surg Res. 6:27. 2011.

17. Hart A, Harvey EJ, Lefebvre LP, Barthelat F, Rabiei R, Martineau PA. Insertion profiles of 4 headless compression screws. J Hand Surg Am. 38:1728–1734. 2013.

18. Herbert TJ, Fisher WE. Management of the fractured scaphoid using a new bone screw. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 66:114–123. 1984.

19. Lee SH, Sung JK. Anterior odontoid fixation using a 4.5-mm Herbert screw: the first report of 20 consecutive cases with odontoid fracture. Surg Neurol. 66:361–366. discussion 366. 2006.

20. Magee W, Hettwer W, Badra M, Bay B, Hart R. Biomechanical comparison of a fully threaded, variable pitch screw and a partially threaded lag screw for internal fixation of type II dens fractures. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 32:E475–E479. 2007.

21. Müller EJ, Wick M, Russe O, Muhr G. Management of odontoid fractures in the elderly. Eur Spine J. 8:360–365. 1999.

22. Platzer P, Thalhammer G, Oberleitner G, Schuster R, Vécsei V, Gaebler C. Surgical treatment of dens fractures in elderly patients. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 89:1716–1722. 2007.

23. Platzer P, Thalhammer G, Ostermann R, Wieland T, Vecsei V, Gaebler C. Anterior screw fixation of odontoid fractures comparing younger and elderly patients. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 32:1714–1720. 2007.

24. Ramaswamy R, Evans S, Kosashvili Y. Holding power of variable pitch screws in osteoporotic, osteopenic and normal bone: are all screws created equal? Injury. 41:179–183. 2010.

25. Tun K, Kaptanoglu E, Cemil B, Yorubulut M, Karahan ST, Tekdemir I. Anatomical study of axis for odontoid screw thickness, length, and angle. Eur Spine J. 18:271–275. 2009.

26. Wong ST, Ernest K, Fan G, Zovickian J, Pang D. Isolated unilateral rupture of the alar ligament. J Neurosurg Pediatr. 13:541–547. 2014.