J Korean Neuropsychiatr Assoc.  2018 May;57(2):145-156. 10.4306/jknpa.2018.57.2.145.

Critique of Mental Health Welfare Law in Korea : Focusing on Involuntary Hospitalization Criteria

• Yoon JS
• Kim CY
• Ahn JH

• KMID: 2419262
• DOI: http://doi.org/10.4306/jknpa.2018.57.2.145

Abstract

Under new mental health and welfare law, involuntary admission is allowed only for persons with mental illness based on the narrowed criteria of mental illness when they meet both need for treatment and danger to themselves and others. These stringent danger criteria along with narrowed definition of mental illness may prevent timely intervention for people with acute psychosis. It is claimed that the danger criteria is essential to keep up with international (UN, WHO) principles for legislation of mental health acts and laws of advanced countries. The international principles, however, do not necessarily call for stringent danger criteria for involuntary hospitalization. Danger criteria are not also prerequisites for involuntary hospitalization in many advanced countries. In countries with strict danger criteria, complementary measures seem to be taken for the drawback of danger criteria. As for the involuntary hospitalization by legal guardians, the complicated qualification for legal guardians may hinder prompt admission. The required number of legal guardians also needs to be changed from two to one person. Even in the situation where involuntary hospitalization is deemed urgent, there is no way to transport the patients to the hospital for assessment or temporary admission unless the police judges the patients to be dangerous to themselves or others. Outpatient treatment order can be an alternative to involuntary admission. However, it is rarely used since the order cannot be applied to those who do not have history of admission due to danger. For voluntary admission, status conversion to involuntary admission needs to be allowed in case of aggravation of symptoms to meet involuntary admission criteria. In addition, informal admission needs to be introduced to avoid unnecessary formal procedures for patients admitting voluntarily to open ward. In view of all these issues with new mental health and welfare law, entire revision of new mental health law is urgent to balance the rights to proper treatments and protection of human rights of persons with mental disorder.

Keyword

Mental Health and Welfare Law; Mental Health Law; Involuntary hospitalization; Mental disorders; Danger criteria; Need for treatment; Human rights

MeSH Terms

Evaluation Studies as Topic*
Hospitalization*
Human Rights
Humans
Jurisprudence*
Korea*
Legal Guardians
Mental Disorders
Mental Health*
Outpatients
Patient Admission
Police
Psychotic Disorders

Reference

1. mohw.go.kr [homepage on the Internet]. Knowing Mental Health and Welfare Law. Ministry of Health and Welfare;cited 2018 May 27. http://www.mohw.go.kr/react/policy/index.jsp?PAR_MENU_ID=06&MENU_ID=06330405&PAGE=5&topTitle=%C1%A4%BD%C5%B0%C7%B0%AD%BA%B9%C1%F6%B9%FD%B9%D9%B7%CE%BE%CB%B1%E2%20-%20%C1%A4%BD%C5%B0%C7%B0%AD%BA%B9%C1%F6%B9%FD%C0%CC%B6%F5.

2. Ministry of Health and Welfare. The mental hygiene law in Taiwan, article 3. Taipei: Mistry of Health and Welfare.

3. Ministry of Health and Welfare. Q&A about Mental Health and Welfare Law. Sejong: Ministry of Health and Welfare;2017.

4. Lee YP. Because, about the controversy of the revised Mental Health Law. The Hankyoreh Post. 2017. 02. 13.

5. General Assembly of the United Nations. principle 16, section 1(b). New York: General Assembly of the United Nations;1991.

6. Freeman M, Pathare S. World Health Organization. section 8.3.2. WHO resource book on mental health, human rights and legislation. Geneva: World Health Organization;2005.

7. Parliament of United Kingdom. chapter 20, part II, section 2, 3, 4. Mental Health Act 1983. London: Parliament of the United Kingdom;1983.

8. Appelbaum PS. Almost a revolution: an international perspective on the law of involuntary commitment. J Am Acad Psychiatry Law. 1997; 25:135–147.

9. Department of Health & Human Services. Mental Health Act 2014 in Victoria, section 5, 29. Melbourne: Department of Health & Human Services;2014.

10. Western Australia Legislation. Mental Health Act 2014 in Western Australia, section 25(1). Perth: Western Australia Legislation;2014.

11. South Australia Legislation. Mental Health Act 2009 in South Australia, section 21(1), 25(2), 29(1). Adelaide: South Australia Legislation;2009.

12. Queensland Legislation. Mental Health Act 2016 in Queensland, commenced on 5 March 2017, section 12(1). Brisbane: Queensland Legislation;2016.

13. Northern Territory Legislation. Mental health and related services act 1998 in Northern territory, section 14. Darwin: Northern Territory Legislation;1998.

14. New South Wales Legislation. Mental Health Act 2007 in New South Wales, section 13, 14, 15. Canberra: New South Wales Legislation;2007.

15. Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care. Mental Health Act, R.S.O. 1990 in Ontario. Chapter M.7, part 2, section 20(1.1)(a). Toronto: Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care;1990.

16. Schizophrenia Society of Ontario. It doesn't work: Unpacking mental health policy and legislation. Ontario: Schizophrenia Society of Ontario;2013. p. 21–22.

17. Zhang S, Mellsop G, Brink J, Wang X. Involuntary admission and treatment of patients with mental disorder. Neurosci Bull. 2015; 31:99–112.

18. British Columbia Legislation. Mental Health Act in British Columbia, [RSBC 1996] chapter 288, section 22(3)(c). British Columbia Legislation;1996.

19. Gray JE, Hastings TJ, Love S, O'Reilly RL. Clinically significant differences among Canadian Mental Health Acts: 2016. Can J Psychiatry. 2016; 61:222–226.

20. Gourevitch R, Brichant-Petitjean C, Crocq MA, Petitjean F. Law & psychiatry: the evolution of laws regulating psychiatric commitment in France. Psychiatr Serv. 2013; 64:609–612.

21. University of Seoul Industry Cooperation Foundation. The improvement of involuntary admission system in the Mental Health Law, and the role of family court. Seoul: Dong sun publishing;2016. p. 233.

22. Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare. The mental health and mentally disabled persons welfare law in Japan, Article 33(1), 29. Tokyo: Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare.

23. University of Seoul Industry Cooperation Foundation. A study for improvement of admission and discharge system in Mental Health Law. Seoul: Jidun publishing;2014. p. 185–186.

24. University of Seoul Industry Cooperation Foundation. A study for improvement of admission and discharge system in Mental Health Law. Seoul: Jidun publishing;2014. p. 181.

25. Ministry of Health and Welfare. The mental hygiene law in Taiwan, article 41. Taipei: Mistry of Health and Welfare.

26. European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights. Involuntary placement and involuntary treatment of persons with mental health problems. Austria: 2012.

27. Testa M, West SG. Civil commitment in the United States. Psychiatry (Edgmont). 2010; 7:30–40.

28. Large MM, Ryan CJ, Nielssen OB, Hyes RA. The danger of dangerousness: why we must remove the dangerousness criterion from our Mental Health Acts. J Med Ethics. 2008; 34:877–881.

29. Brian S. N.Y.'s true mental health problem. New York Daily News Post. 2013. 01. 23. Sect. Opinion.

30. Washington State Institute for Public Policy. Involuntary civil commitments: common questions and a review of state practices. Washington State Institute for Public Policy;2015.

31. University of Seoul Industry Cooperation Foundation. The improvement of involuntary admission system in the Mental Health Law, and the role of family court. Seoul: Dong sun publishing;2016. p. 133–137.

32. Iowa State Legislation. Iowa code 2018, chapter 229 hospitalization of persons with mental illness, Article 229.1(20). Des Moine: Iowa State Legislation;2018.

33. Ministry of Health and Welfare. Advance legislation notice of Mental Health Law enforcement regulations(draft). Sejong: Ministry of Health and Welfare;2017. p. 94.

34. Ministry of Health and Welfare, National Center for Mental Health. The guideline of admission and discharge process in new Mental Health and Welfare Law. Sejong: Ministry of Health and Welfare;2017.

35. search.ccourt.go.kr [homepage on the Internet]. 2014 Heon-ga 9 Dated Sep 29, 2016. Unconstitutionality of the Mental Health Law article 24(1). Constitutional Court of Korea. cited 2018 May 27. Available from: http://search.ccourt.go.kr/ths/pr/ths_pr0101_P1.do?seq=0&cname=&eventNum=41196&eventNo=2014%ED%97%8C%EA%B0%809&pubFlag=0&cId=010200&selectFont=.

36. Parliament of the United Kingdom. Mental Health Act 1983, Part II, section 26. London: Parliament of the United Kingdom;1983.

37. University of Seoul Industry Cooperation Foundation. A study for improvement of admission and discharge system in Mental Health Law. Seoul: Jidun publishing;2014. p. 126.

38. Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care. Mental Health Act, R.S.O. 1990 in Ontario. Chapter M.7, part 2, section 20(1.1)(e). Toronto: Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care;1990.

39. Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care. Health Care Consent Act 1996 S.O. in Ontario. Chapter 2 schedule A, part 2 consention incapable person's behalf, section 20(1). Toronto: Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care;1990.

40. Park KC. Legal basis for the mentally ill and housing mentally ill in Germany. Ewha Law Journal. 2014; 19:357–394.

41. University of Seoul Industry Cooperation Foundation. A study for improvement of admission and discharge system in Mental Health Law. Seoul: Jidun publishing;2014. p. 78.

42. University of Seoul Industry Cooperation Foundation. The improvement of involuntary admission system in the Mental Health Law, and the role of family court. Seoul: Dong sun publishing;2016. p. 244.

43. Yoon JS, Ahn JS, Yoon W, Kim CY. The new mental health and welfare law in Korea: issues with additional diagnosis by external psychiatrists and the role of the Admission Review Committee. J Korean Neuropsychiatr Assoc. 2017; 56:146–153.

44. Uijeongbu District Court. 2016 Go-dan 3898 Dated Jun 11,2016. Violation of the Mental Health Law. Uijeongbu: Uijeongbu District Court;2016.

45. Parliament of the United Kingdom. Mental Health Act 1983, section 4. London: Parliament of the United Kingdom;1983.

46. Sadock BJ, Sadock VA, Ruiz P. Kaplan & sadock's synopsis of psychiatry: behavioral sciences/clinical psychiatry. 11th ed. Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins;2015.

47. Freeman M, Pathare S. section 8.1. World Health Organizations. WHO resource book on mental health, human rights and legislation. Geneva: World Health Organizations;2005.

48. Parliament of the United Kingdom. Mental Capacity Act 2005 in UK. section 3. London: Parliament of the United Kingdom;2005.

49. Department of Health & Human Services. Mental Health Act 2014 in Victoria. section 68-70. Melbourne: Department of Health & Human Services;2014.

50. Ministry of Government Legislation. The Mental Health and Welfare Law. Article 43(1), 44(4). Sejong: Ministry of Government Legislation.

51. Ministry of Government Legislation. The Mental Health and Welfare Law. Article 41. Sejong: Ministry of Government Legislation.

52. Yoon JS, Joo YH, Ahn JH, Kim CY. Admission status conversion from voluntary into involuntary, is it illegal. J Korean Neuropsychiatr Assoc. 2016; 55:357–364.

53. Health & Welfare Committee. Health and Welfare Committee 1st proceeding. The 19th National Assembly of Korea, 342nd. National Assembly Minutes. 2016. 04. 29.

54. Rosanna E, Jeffrey G, Kristina R. A guide for implementing assisted outpatient treatment. Arlington: Treatment Advocacy Center;2012. p. 7.

55. Ministry of Government Legislation. The Mental Health and Welfare Law. Article 64(1). Sejong: Ministry of Government Legislation.

56. Rosanna E, Jeffrey G, Kristina R. A guide for implementing assisted outpatient treatment. Arlington: Treatment Advocacy Center;2012. p. 11.

57. Western Australia Legislation. Mental Health Act 2014 in Western Australia, section 25(2). Perth: Western Australia Legislation;2014.

58. New South Wales Legislation. Mental Health Act 2007 in New South Wales, section 51(3). Canberra: New South Wales Legislation;2007.

59. Northern Territory Legislation. Mental health and related services act 1998 in Northern territory, section 16. Darwin: Northern Territory Legislation;1998.

60. Queensland Legislation. Mental Health Act 2016 in Queensland, commenced on 5 March 2017, section 18(4). Brisbane: Queensland Legislation;2016.

61. South Australia Legislation. Mental Health Act 2009 in South Australia, section 10, 16. Adelaide: South Australia Legislation;2009.

62. Parliament of the United Kingdom. Mental Health Act 1983, section 17A. London: Parliament of the United Kingdom;1983.

63. Swartz MS, Bhattacharya S, Robertson AG, Swanson JW. Involuntary outpatient commitment and the elusive pursuit of violence prevention: a view from the United States. Can J Psychiatry. 2017; 62:102–108.

64. Segal SP, Hayes SL, Rimes L. The utility of outpatient commitment: I. a need for treatment and a least restrictive alternative to psychiatric hospitalization. Psychiatr Serv. 2017; 68:1247–1254.