J Korean Med Assoc.  2016 Oct;59(10):763-770. 10.5124/jkma.2016.59.10.763.

Analysis of broadcasting review trends after enacting the Guidelines on promotional mass media appearances by physicians

• Kim C

• KMID: 2391514
• DOI: http://doi.org/10.5124/jkma.2016.59.10.763

Abstract

Recently, as the general public has taken a greater interest in healthful lifestyles, the mass media became the public's core informant on health and medical information. However, serious violations of the broadcasting review regulations have occurred in health and medical broadcasting programs. In fact, many problems stem from the lack of expertise and ethics of physicians. Therefore, a more thorough verification of health and medical information and the selection of the physicians to appear on broadcasting is needed. In 2015, the Korean Medical Association established the Guidelines on promotional mass media appearances by physicians in order to reduce these problems. This study aimed to identify the problems with the health and medical programs, including an analysis of review results and cases and to explore ways to address the problems. We found that cases of violation of the broadcasting review regulations were increasing and the violation level was becoming more serious. We also found that the articles of the Korea Communications Standards Regulation that have been most often violated are Article 42 (medical treatment, etc.) and 46 (advertising effect). The cases violating both of these two articles comprised 96.5% of the total of 85 cases in 2015; these are involved with the expertise and ethics of physicians. In light of this, it is especially worth noting some physicians so called 'show doctor (named by Korean Medical Association)' appear on mass media and recommend specific treatments or products for marketing purpose. In conclusion, physicians to appear on broadcasting shall provide objective and evidence-based medical information with professional ethics.

Keyword

Korean Medical Association; Guideline; Review; Physicians; Mass media

MeSH Terms

Ethics
Ethics, Professional
Korea
Life Style
Marketing
Mass Media*
Social Control, Formal

Reference

1. Lee HJ, Park JY. Correlations between old people's watching of television programs and practice of health behaviors. J Korea Contents Assoc. 2011; 11:294–301.

2. You HS. Health behavior and program cognition by audience's attitude toward health program of broadcast [dissertation]. Seoul: Yonsei University;2001.

3. Park SH, Chang HJ, Kwon YD. Study on the influence of health information from TV: amusement programs on practice of health behavior. Korean J Health Educ Promot. 2003; 20:187–202.

4. Kang YW. Korean Medical Association, providing guidelines on promotional mass media appearances by physicians. Medical Today. 2015 Mar 27. cited 2016 Aug 31. Available from: http://www.mdtoday.co.kr/mdtoday/index.html?no=251966.

5. Korean Medical Association. Guidelines on promotional mass media appearances by physicians. Seoul: Korean Medical Association;2015.

6. Choo MJ, Shin DC, Kang CH, Shin HY. World Medical Association guidelines on promotional mass media appearances by physicians: starting campaigns for ethics. J Korean Med Sci. 2015; 30:1716–1717.

7. WMA guidelines on promotional mass media appearances by physicians. J Korean Med Sci. 2015; 30:1715.

8. Korea Communications Standards Commission. Special reviews on local TV medical·health programs with problems [Internet]. Seoul: Korea Communications Standards Commission;2010. cited 2016 Aug 31. Available from: http://www.kocsc.or.kr/04_know/Press_View.php?ko_board=Press&ba_id=2862&page=53.

9. Jung JH. A study of the problems and the improvements on health and medical broadcasting program. Trends Korea Commun Stand. 2015; (11):92–116.

10. Im UY. Doctor vs drug peddler? Do you know Show Doctor?. Chosun Media. 2015 Jul 23. cited 2016 Aug 31. Available from: http://pub.chosun.com/client/news/viw.asp?cate=C01&mcate=M1003&nNewsNumb=20150717908&nidx=17910.

11. Shin HY. 'Show doctors' and Korean Medical Association's efforts for self-regulation. World Med J. 2016; 62:5–7.

12. Sung YK. Korean Communications Standards Commission, special reviews on health and medical broadcasting programs. Money Today. 2015 May 7. cited 2016 Aug 31. Available from: http://www.mt.co.kr/view/mtview.php?type=1&no=2015050711591154513&outlink=1.