J Korean Med Assoc.  2011 Mar;54(3):332-341.

How to develop social consensus for the uninsured benefit in the social insurance system

• Kim KH
• Kim HN
• Yi SD
• Park YH

Abstract

The current national health-insurance system of the Republic of Korea uses the negative-list method to determine benefit coverage, which includes most medical services. However, financial limitations have led to frequent conflicts between medical-service providers and the Health Insurance Review and Assessment Service (HIRA) about the inclusion of specific service-providers' practices within benefit coverage. The role of HIRA is to determine whether payments claimed by service providers are clinically valid and formulated in a cost-efficient manner. This article describes the present state and structure of the benefit system in the Korean national health-insurance system. We focus on issues of arbitrary uninsured benefits that may arise when service providers request patients to pay in full (with their approval) for a service that is not included in the benefits, according to the National Health Insurance Act. We also consider the legal treatment of arbitrary uninsured benefits in Korea and other countries. We suggest measures to improve the payment system for arbitrary uninsured benefits in Korea. Laws and regulations should be revised to cover these arbitrary uninsured benefits in a manner that can be agreed upon by HIRA, service providers, and patients.

Keyword

National Health Insurance; Benefit coverage system; Arbitrary uninsured benefits

MeSH Terms

Consensus
Humans
Insurance, Health
Jurisprudence
Korea
Medically Uninsured
National Health Programs
Republic of Korea
Social Control, Formal
Social Security

Reference

1. Lee KS. Reform plan for management system of health insurance. 2005. Seoul: Korean Medical Association.

2. Kim YI. A study on management of arbitrary uninsured benefits. 2000. Seoul: Seoul National University, The Graduate School of Public Health.

3. Moon OR. Long-term improvement of health insurance payment system. 2006. Seoul: Seoul National University, The Graduate School of Public Health.

4. Jo JK. Policy forum: A study on improvements of arbitrary uninsured benefits. 2010. Seoul: Korean Medical Association.

5. Press release 2011 Feb 17 [Internet]. Health Insurance Review and Assessment Service. cited 2011 Feb 20. Seoul: Health Insurance Review and Assessment Service 2011;Available from: http://www.hira.or.kr/common/dummyjsp?pgmid=HIRAA060200000000.

6. Jo YH. A study on acceptance of arbitrary uninsured benefits. 2007. Association of Court Case Studies.

7. Jo HC, Jeong HK. National health insurance law. 2005. Seoul: Korea Legislation Research Institute.

8. Jang W. Legal nature of the medical contract in health insurance [dissertation]. 2001. Seoul: Yonsei University.

9. Kim NK. The problem of the Korean health insurance system: in order to control the health care of the Ministry of Health. Hum Rights Justice. 2009. (392):73–88.

10. Lee SH. Reform plan for the advanced health system. 2007. Seoul: Korean Medical Association, Research Institute for Healthcare Policy.

11. Report to the congress: issues in a modernized medicare program [Internet]. MedPAC. 2005. cited 2011 Feb 20. New Jersey: MedPAC;Available from: http://www.medpac.gov/documents/june05_entire_report.pdf.

12. Waiver of liability form [Internet]. Center for Medicare & Medicaid Service. cited 2011 Feb 20. Baltimore: Center for Medicare & Medicaid Service;Available from: http://www.cms.gov/.

13. Choi YS, Kim JH, Lee HY, Han JT. The actual condition and management of uninsured medical expense. 2007. Seoul: National Health Insurance Corporation.

14. Oh EH. Prohibition system of mixed care and new medical technology in Japan. 2007. Seoul: Health Insurance Review and Assessment Service.

15. Nam SY, Kwon OJ, Kim OJ. The study on Japanese health care insurance and medical service reimbursement system. 2010. Seoul: Korean Medical Association, Research Institute for Healthcare Policy.

16. Jeong HJ, Lee YG, Lee HY. Improvement of national health insurer's role for the management of medical care benefits. 2009. Seoul: Health Insurance Policy Research Institute.

17. Jeong SH, Jo SJ. Improvement about decision process of medical care benefits. 2009. Seoul: Health Insurance Review & Assessment Service, Research & Development Center.