J Korean Fract Soc.  2002 Oct;15(4):504-510.

The Fate of Large Butterfly Fragments in Femoral Shaft Comminuted Fractures Treated withClosed Interlocking Intramedullary Nailing

• Lee KB
• Chung JY
• Moon ES
• Song EK
• Jeong KC

Abstract

PURPOSE: To evaluate the radiographic changes and union of large butterfly fragments after closed interlocking IM nailing for femoral shaft comminuted fractures.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The objects of this study were 23 cases(15 males, 8 females) of femoral shaft comminuted fractures with butterfly fragments larger than 5cm and with the follow up period of 12 months or more from June 1995 to June 2000. We assessed the size, the degrees of displacement and angulation of the large butterfly fragments at preoperatively, one day, one month and three month postoperatively and evaluated the union at four month and six month postoperatively.
RESULTS
The size of the fragments was 8.4cm (5.0-13.0) in average. The distance between the fragment and shaft was 15.9cm preoperatively and 10.1, 7.7, 6.8cm at one day, one month and three month postoperatively. In 13 cases of angulation over 5 degrees, it changed from 19.6 degrees preoperatively to 13.9 degrees , 8.4 degrees , 5 . 9 degrees at one day, one month and three month postoperatively. There is no increase in angulation.The union was completed at 4 months in 13 cases (56.5%) and at 6 months in all except one case of delayed union, in which we did not do any further procedure until the union was achieved.
CONCLUSION
In femoral shaft comminuted fractures with displaced large butterfly fragments treated with closed interlocking IM nailing, the distance and angulation of fragments decreased gradually and even the fragments were inverted or largely displaced and angulated the fragments were united. So the caution must be given not to displace the fragments intraoperatively and to keep anatomical position of the fragments by active exercise and hydrostatic pressure of the muscles of thigh postoperatively. Then the open reduction and internal fixations of the fragments will not be necessary.

Keyword

Femoral shaft comminuted fracture; Large butterfly fragment; Closed interlocking IM nailing

MeSH Terms

Butterflies*
Follow-Up Studies
Fracture Fixation, Intramedullary*
Fractures, Comminuted*
Humans
Hydrostatic Pressure
Male
Muscles
Thigh