Hemoglobin Variability Associated with Different Erythropoiesis Stimulating Agents in Hemodialysis Patients

Park, Su Kyoung; Hwang, Kyu Sig; Park, Joon Sung; Lee, Chang Hwa; Kang, Chong Myung; Kim, Gheun Ho

Abstract

PURPOSE
This study was undertaken to examine whether differences exist in the hemoglobin variability according to the types of erythropoiesis stimulating agent (ESA) in hemodialysis (HD) patients.
METHODS
Clinical data were retrospectively analyzed from 72 patients on maintenance hemodialysis who were using darbepoetin alfa (n=27), epoetin beta (n=27), and epoetin alpha (n=18). As parameters of hemoglobin variability, hemoglobin cycling, the variance of hemoglobin and the SD/mean of hemoglobin were analyzed. Hemoglobin cycling was defined as the presence of cycles with an amplitude >1.5 g/dL and lasting more than 2 months.
RESULTS
Hemoglobin cycling was present in 53 (73.6%) out of 72 HD patients. Hemoglobin cycling in patients receiving darbepoetin alfa had greater frequency (1.63+/-0.93 vs. 1.00+/-0.88 times/year, p<0.05), amplitude (2.88+/-1.48 vs. 1.88+/-1.60 g/dL, p<0.05), and velocity (1.21+/-0.74 vs. 0.73+/-0.66 g/dL/month, p<0.05) than that in patients receiving epoetin beta. The variance of hemoglobin in patients receiving epoetin beta (0.79+/-0.53 g/dL) was smaller than that in patients receiving darbepoetin alfa (1.29+/-0.70 g/dL, p<0.05) and epoetin alfa (1.08+/-0.52 g/dL, p<0.05). Also, the ratio of SD/mean of hemoglobin in patients receiving epoetin beta (8.20+/-2.59%) was lower than that in patients receiving darbepoetin alfa (10.81+/-2.10%, p<0.05) and epoetin alfa (10.30+/-2.10%, p<0.05).
CONCLUSION
Hemoglobin variability is differential according to various ESAs, and it may be less with epoetin beta compared with darbepoetin alpha and epoetin alpha.