Korean J Dermatol.
2007 Feb;45(2):111-118.
Histopathologic Gradings Correlate with Clinical Prognostic Factors and Therapeutic Effects in Patient with Alopecia Areata
- Affiliations
-
- 1Department of Dermatology, Dong-A University College of Medicine, Busan, Korea. khkim@dau.ac.kr
Abstract
-
BACKGRUND & OBJECTIVE: Prognosis of alopecia areata have been attributed to various factors; age of onset, duration before treatment, extent of hair loss, clinical type of alopecia areata, sex, nail changes or accompaniment of atopy. The study on prognostic factors has only been conducted from statistical data of patients and individualized medical conditions. The histopathologic findings of alopecia areata have been investigated by the minute pathologic changes associated with the hair growth cycle in the transverse section. Moreover, these findings were used mainly for diagnostic purpose, but clinical significance of histopathologic severity in prognosis has not been established to date.
METHODS
A clinical study, including histopathological and clinical evaluation was conducted on 108 alopecia areata patients between July 1997 and August 2005 at the Department of Dermatology, Dong-A University Hospital. The evaluation criteria INCLUDED: sex, age, age at onset, duration before treatment, clinical types, extent of hair loss, nail changes, accompaniment of atopy, and scalp biopsy finding. The clinical types of alopecia areata were classified as follows; patchy, subtotalis, totalis, and universalis. The extent of hair loss before treatment was classified into 5 grades (S1~S5), according to the method designed by Olsen and Canfield. Clinical improvements after treatment were classified into 5 grades according to degree of regrowth and reduction of the alopecia areata area. Biopsy findings were classified into 4 grades (type I, II, III, and IV) according to classification by Uno and Orecchia.
RESULTS
The mean age was 28.6 years, without any sex predominance. The severe histopathologic gradings were significantly associated with early age of onset (p=0.008), a long disease duration before treatment (p=0.003), a greater extent of hair loss (p=0.009), and poor response to treatment (p=0.036). The histopathologic gradings were not significantly associated with sex (p=0.657), clinical types of alopecia areata (p=0.529), nail changes (p=0.746), or accompaniment of atopy (p=0.924).
CONCLUSION
Histopathologic gradings in alopecia areata, using vertical sections are significantly associated with prognostic factors such as age of onset, extent of hair loss, disease duration before treatment, as well as the response to treatment. Therefore we consider that the histopathologic grading system is recommendable as an independent prognostic factor in alopecia areata, in addition to the well-known clinical prognostic factors. They may also be used to predict the response to treatment.
