Evaluation of Long term Outcome with the Hypertensive Intracerebral Hemorrhage: A Comparative Study of Surgical and Conservative Treatment in 1009 Cases

Lim, Young Jin; Lee, Ki Hong; Kim, Tae Sung; Kim, Gook Ki; Rhee, Bong Arm; Leem, Won

Abstract

Hypertensive intracerebral hemorrhage is one of the important diseases in Korea, sociomedically, in view of high incidence and mortality rate of the disease, severity of its sequelae and the affected productive age-group of 40 to 50 years old. The indications for surgery in hypertensive intracerebral hemorrhage are still controversial. The reason for this may be : 1) lack of adequate and comparable data in conservative and surgical therapy from the same institution : 2) lack of adequate close follow-up monitoring over an extended period of time ; or 3) lack of proper classification of hematomas for comparison of results from different institutions. The authors analysed 1009 cases of hypertensive intracerebral hemorrhage admitted to the Department of Neurosurgery, Kyung-Hee University Medical center for five years from January 1983 to December 1987. The site of hemorrhage have classified according to their anatomical site on computerized tomography. The long term outcome was analysed with reference to comparison between surgical treatment and conservative treatment. The results were as follows : 1) The incidence was high in the age-group of 50 years old and the sex ration was 1.23 : 1.0. 2) There was no seasonal variation in the incidence. 3) The occurrence of putamino-thalamic hemorrhage(38.7%) was most frequent, and then followed by putaminal(17.9%), thalamic(17.9%), subcortical(13.6%), pontine(7.5%), cerebellar(4.4%) hemorrhage in order. 4) The outcome was satisfactory in the cases of subcortical hemorrhage and cerebellar hemorrhage. The outcome was poorest in the cases of pontine hemorrhage. Both putamen and thalamic hemorrhage had brought about a high licidence of severe sequelae. 5) In correlation between the therapeutic modality and the outcome, surgical treatment increased the frequency of improvement towards Grade I-II, and also decreased the frequency of Grade III, but brought about the increase of the mortality rate. In general this results failed to support the view that the surgical treatment is superior to the conservative one in the management of hypertensive intracerebral hemorrhage. But, in the subcortical and cerebellar hemorrhage, surgical treatment showed better outcome than conservative treatment. 6) The outcome was poor in large sized hemorrhage than small one. In cases with large sized subcortical and cerebellar hemorrhage, surgical treatment had low mortality rate. 7) The level of consciousness at attack had closely related to the outcome. 8) In correlation between the time interval from ictus till operation and outcome, generally speaking, the outcome of delayed operation was slightly better than early operation. But, when the level of consciousness was good, the outcome of early operation was satisfactory. 9) Intraventricular hemorrhage occurred in 38.9% of all cases, and most frequently associated with thalamic hemorrhage. In the case of association with intraventricular hemorrhage, the mortality rate was greatly increased than in cases without intraventricular hemorrhage. 10) As far as the causes of death were concerned, cerebral swelling was most frequent and overall mortality rate was 22%.