Early Surgery Extraventricular Drainage, Cisternal Drainage with Nimodipine Irrigation and Intravenous Nimodipine for Ruptured Intracranial Aneurysms

Kim, Byung Kyu; Yim, Man Bin; Son, Eun Ik; Kim, Dong Won; Lee, Jung Kyo; Kim, In Hong

Abstract

During the eleven months from September, 1989 to July, 1990, a total of 118 subarachnoid hemorrhage(SAH) patients were admitted. Among these, in 2 cases, the etiology was unknown and another 8 cases of Hunt & Hess clinical grade V patients died in the emergency room or intensive care unit within 24 hours after admission. The remaning 108 cases were managed with protocol as follows. 1) Surgery was done within 9 days after the SAH(total 67 cases) : Extraventricular drainage(EVD) was performed and a cisternal drainage(CD) catheter was positioned during surgery. EVD, CD nimodipine irrigation(0.4mg) through the CD catheter, and intravenous injection(IV) of nimodipine(1~2mg/hr)continued for 13days after the SAH. 2) Surgery was done after the 9th SAH day due to late transfer neurology or other hospitals or posterior circulation aneurysms(32 cases), and 9 cases refused surgery : Nimodipine was used orally(240mg/day) in 35 cases and an IV route(1~2mg/hr) in 6 cases. Total management outcome and results were obtained as follows. 1) A total unsatisfactory management outcome was 18.52%(serve disabled : 4.63%, vegetative : 0.93%, death : 12.96%. In the surgical cases only, 40.8%, 1.02%, 9.19%, respectively). 2) An unsatisfactory surgical outcome in cases following surgery after the 9th SAH day was 6.24%(severe disabled : 3.12%, death : 3.12%). 3) An unsatisfactory management outcome in cases of admission grades I & II following surgery within the 9th SAH day or those non-surgical patients was 19.15%(severe disabled : 4.25%, death : 14.89%. In surgical cases only 2.33%, 9.30%, respectively). 4) An unsatisfactory management outcome in cases of admission grades III & IV with surgery within the 9th SAH day or non-surgical patients was 29.63%(severe disabled : 7.41%, vegetative : 3.70%. death : 18.52%. In surgical cases only 9.09%, 4.55%, 13.64%, respectively). One case of admission grade V died. 5) Causes of unsatisfactory outcome were vasospasm : 9 cases(8.33%), SAH itself : 4 cases, rebleeding : 3 cases, surgical complication : 1 case, medical complication : 1 case, anesthesia : 1 case, and head trauma : 1 case. 6) Complications in management protocol with EVD, CD, CD nimodipine irrigation, and IV of nimodipine were transient hypotension(1 case) and meningitis(5 cases). These complications were improved without sequelae with discontinuing the IV of nimodipine and using antibiotics. We concluded that this protocol may improved the total management outcome of aneurysmal SAH patients, especially poor grade patients(Hunt & Hess grade III & IV) without significant complications. However, in spite of this protocol, the leading cause of an unsatisfactory outcome is vasospasm.